On
Sunday, the New Orleans Saints open their season against the Arizona Cardinals
in Phoenix. As they start their 2015 campaign, the Black and Gold look to
rebound from last year’s 7-9 season, their second such finish in the last three
years. As we’ve discussed in previous posts, the Saints aggressively retooled
their roster in the offseason, desperate to improve a defense that finished 31st
according to Football Outsiders’ Defense Adjusted Value Over Average (DVOA—a statistic
that calculates the outcome of every single play and compares it to league
average—DVOA is expressed in a percentage with 0 as league average, offenses
want to have positive DVOAs, defenses negative ones). In the Drew Brees era,
the Saints have consistently been a top-flight offense and constructed their
defense around generating turnovers. In 2009 that strategy paid off as the
Saints triumphed over the Indianapolis Colts in Super Bowl XLIV. The Saints
insistence on trading up in the draft and backloading free agent contracts has
nearly crippled the team’s salary cap and caused this season’s offseason
frenzy. If the Saints have any hope of being Super Bowl contenders, they’ll
need their defense to take a significant step forward. So let’s break the
Saints down by offense, defense, and special teams.
OFFENSE:
|
DVOA
(rank)
|
Weighted
DVOA (rank)
|
Pass DVOA
(rank)
|
Rush DVOA
(rank)
|
2014
|
10.6% (7)
|
5.2% (9)
|
21.6% (9)
|
0.8% (9)
|
Quarterbacks: Drew Brees, Luke
McCown, Garrett Grayson
Reports of Drew Brees’ demise as
an elite NFL quarterback have been grossly exaggerated. In 2014, Brees finished
4th among NFL QBs in DYAR (a Football Outsiders metric that adjusts
a QB’s passing yards to league average) behind only Ben Roethlisburger, Aaron
Rodgers, and Peyton Manning. On a per play basis, Brees was sixth among
quarterbacks with a 15.7% DVOA (Brady and Romo jumped ahead of him). Brees
remained excellent in connecting with his wide receivers on short throws completing
74% of his passes thrown within 10 yards of the line of scrimmage. He got in
trouble when he tried to force the ball down the field completing only 22 of 52
passes (42.3%). So keep an eye on those downfield throws, if Brees can consistently
connect with wide receiver Brandin Cooks, the Saints will be in good shape.
McCown enters another year as Brees’ backup and that’s all there’s to say about
him. Grayson was a 3rd round pick this year and will spend the
season as a developmental project.
Running Backs: Mark Ingram, C.J.
Spiller, Khiry Robinson, Tim Hightower, Austin Johnson, Marcus Murphy
The Saints gave up a 2nd
round pick in 2011 and 1st rounder in 2012 to trade up for Ingram.
In 2014, Ingram finally showed some signs of life after being plagued by
injuries and ineffectiveness. He ran for 964 yards, averaging 4.3 yards per
carry. According to Football Outsiders metrics, Ingram ranked 14th
in both DYAR (108) and DVOA (2.7%). The Saints then resigned him to a four
year, sixteen million dollar contract. If he can build off 2014, Ingram will be
worth the money. The Saints then signed the speedy and oft injured C.J. Spiller
to a nearly identical contract (4 years, 16 million). Spiller is a speedy
runner, but one who has only managed a single thousand yard season. For a team
in salary cap hell to invest so much money in their second running back boggles
the mind. Especially since Khiry Robinson was an undrafted free agent who has
exceeded expectations. Tim Hightower will serve as a change of pace back,
Johnson is primarily a fullback who will block and catch some passes out of the
backfield, and Murphy is primarily a special teams player.
Wide Receivers/Tight Ends: WR: Brandin Cooks, Marques Colston, Brandon Coleman, Willie Snead, TE: Benjamin Watson,
Josh Hill
The Saints open the season thin
in the pass catching department. They’ll need Cooks, their first round pick
from 2014 (and the only player from that draft still on the active roster), to
stay healthy and become a viable deep threat for Brees. Cooks showed his
potential in the preseason game against the Patriots, catching four passes for
117 yards and a 45 yard touchdown reception. Marques Colston remains an aging,
but steady option in the passing game. Look for him to collect a lot of those
short passes from Brees. Coleman and Snead are both second year players who
spent time on the practice squad last season. Watson and Hill will look to
replace Jimmy Graham’s production in the passing game. Watson is the veteran
and better blocker, while Hill is younger and the better receiver.
Offensive Line: Centers: Max Unger, Senio Kelemete
Guards: Mike McGlynn, Tim Lelito, Jahri Evans, Senio Kelemete
Tackles: Terron Armstead, Andreas Peat, Zack Strief
The Saints retooled their
offensive line in the offseason. Unger came over from Seattle in the Jimmy
Graham trade and Peat was drafted with the 13th overall pick. When
healthy, Unger anchored the middle of the Seahawks rushing attack. With the
Saints renewed focus on the running game, they will need strong offensive line
to open up holes for Ingram and Spiller. They will also need to give Brees time
in the pocket as he adjusts to life without Jimmy Graham.
DEFENSE
|
DVOA
(rank)
|
Weighted
DVOA (rank)
|
Pass DVOA
(rank)
|
Rush DVOA
(rank)
|
2014
|
13.1% (31)
|
9.0% (28)
|
19.2% (27)
|
14.6% (32)
|
Defensive Linemen/Linebackers:
DT: Kaleb Eulis, John Jenkins, Kevin Williams, Tyeler Davison
DE: Cameron Jordan, Aikeem Hicks,
Bobby Richardson, Tavaris Barnes,
Linebackers: Hau’oli Kikaha,
Stephone Anthony, Ramon Humber, Davis Tull, David Hawthorne, Dannell Ellerbe,
Kassim Edebali
No matter how you look at it, the
Saints defense was atrocious last year. And the defensive front seven is the
weakest area on the entire roster. Cam Jordan is a Pro Bowl caliber pass rusher
and defensive lineman—other than that? The Saints will rely on two rookies,
Kikaha and Anthony to start at linebacker. Anthony will play inside alongside veteran
castoff Dannel Ellerbe. Kikaha will play outside and rush the passer behind
Jordan. Look for opponents to run up the middle against the Saints defensive
tackles. In 2014, the Saints defense allowed opponents to convert 74% of their
runs on 3rd or 4th down with two yards or fewer for
either a touchdown or a first down. Last season, the Saints defense forced
three and outs on only 13.9% of opponent’s drives, worst in the NFL. They’ll
need to do better than that in 2015.
Defensive Backs: CBs: Keenan
Lewis, Brandon Browner, Delvin Breaux, Brian Dixon, Kyle Wilson, Damian Swann
S: Jairus Byrd, Rafael Bush,
Kenny Vaccaro, Jamarca Sanford
If the Saints secondary can stay
healthy—and that may be tough with Lewis out for at least the first month of
the season—they will be the strength of the defense. The Saints imported
Brandon Browner to line up opposite Lewis. Browner is a tall and physical
corner who matches up well against bigger wide receivers. He also draws a
ridiculous amount of penalties, accounting for 15 penalties in 12 games for the
Patriots last season. If Byrd can return to the player he was in Buffalo, he
can roam the middle of the field searching for interceptions and providing
safety help. This would allow Vaccaro, who struggled mightily in his second
reason, to play to his strengths, near the line of scrimmage and in run
support.
SPECIAL TEAMS
P Thomas Morstead
K Zack Hocker
Morstead remains one of the very
best punters and kickoff specialists in the league. Hocker is largely unknown
as a kicker, but in Sean Payton’s time with the Saints, he’s recognized that kickers
are largely replaceable. So if Hocker struggles, the Saints will just bring in
someone else.
PREDICTION
The Saints retooled offense will
run the ball a little more, rely on short passes and finish in the top 10. It
would be difficult for the Saints to repeat last year’s defensive debacle. But they
will continue to struggle, especially upfront where the lack of top flight
talent really hurts. Anthony and Kikaha have a lot of upside, but it will take
time for them to develop. I think finishing between 20 and 25 in defensive DVOA
is a reasonable expectation. With Brees and Payton heading the offense, the
Saints floor is about 6 wins. With that defense, the ceiling is about 10 wins.
I’ll lean towards the ceiling and predict the Saints go 9-7.